Best Bobby Pins When Ordinary Pins Keep Slipping

The best professional bobby pins for thick hair are Goody Black Roller Pins, because a 3-inch straight pin reaches deeper into a packed section than the drugstore 2-inch standard, and 18 of them cost the least in this set. If you want a single box that handles both heavy sections and fine flyaways, the Goody SlideProof XXL box of 16 is the better call. Most buyers compare pin counts. That is the wrong first move. A box of 300 short pins will still pop out of a dense bun, while a dozen long ones will hold it, so length and grip pattern decide this before quantity ever enters the picture.

Best professional bobby pins for thick hair at a glance

Which profile do you actually fit?

I screened these seven around four buyer profiles, because the pins split neatly by who is holding them. Nobody needs all four boxes.

1. The daily bun wearer. You pin the same shape every morning and lose pins in the sofa. You need long pins in a small, cheap box you replace often. Goody Black Roller Pins and the Goody SlideProof XXL box are built for you.
2. The working stylist. You pin ten heads a day and you cannot run dry mid-set. Count matters as much as length. The Wenobby 100-piece set and the MORGLES 120-piece box fit here.
3. The event buyer. One wedding, one recital, one season. You want length and enough pins to over-pack the kit. Aswewamt's 50 pins at 3.34 in and Tyqour's 30 at 3.35 in cover it.
4. The finisher. Your bun is already anchored. You want discreet pins for wraps, edges and baby hairs. Diane's 2.5 in curved pins are the shortest here, which is exactly the point.

One warning about the search phrase itself. Several of these listings advertise thick hair in their own titles, but nothing in the published data measures holding power. Length, count, colour and shape are the facts. The rest is the manufacturer talking, so treat "for thick hair" as a hint rather than a specification, and judge on the figures.

Does length or grip decide the hold?

Length is the specification that separates these seven, and it is the one a shopper can actually compare. The spread runs from 2.5 in on the Diane pins up to 3.35 in on the Tyqour set. That 0.85 in gap is enormous at this scale. It is the difference between a pin that spans a section and a pin that sits on top of it.

Grip pattern is the second variable. MORGLES describes a crinkle in the middle on one side, which is the classic ridged bobby pin construction. Wenobby's pins are U shaped, an open two-leg design with no spring tension, which behaves differently: it slides into a bun and locks by friction rather than by clamping. Diane's are curved and flat.

Here is the trick with dense hair. A ridged pin grips the hair it clamps. A U pin grips the hair it passes through. In a very packed bun, the U pin often survives longer, because there is no spring to fatigue. In a loose twist, it has nothing to bite. That is why the professional pick and the overall pick in this guide are different shapes.

Tip finish matters too, and only some listings mention it. Diane and Wenobby both describe coated ball tips. Goody's roller pins publish nothing about tips at all.

1. Goody Black Roller Pins — Best overall

A plain 3-inch black pin at the lowest price position in this set, which makes it the cheapest way to find out whether long pins fix your slipping problem.

Best for: anyone building daily buns who wants a straight 3-inch pin Skip it if: you need a large stash for a busy salon day

This is the oldest listing in the group, on the market since 2009, and the least decorated. The card holds 18 pins at 3 inches, and the whole package weighs 0.28 g on its published figure, which tells you these are light-gauge roller pins rather than heavy jumbo stock. Goody's own copy says only that they help secure hair in place and suit all hair types, which is about as thin as feature copy gets.

Why it still leads. Of the seven, this is the cheapest and it clears 3 inches. Everything shorter in the set costs more. If your existing drugstore pins slide out of a thick section, the variable you want to change first is length, and this is the least expensive way to change it. Roller pins are also straight rather than ridged, so they thread through a wrapped section smoothly instead of dragging.

The trade-off against the rest of the set is stock and information. 18 pins is the second-smallest count here, and nothing is published about tip coating, so you cannot know from the listing whether the ends are finished.

Pros:

• Cheapest of the seven picks
• Full 3 in length in an entry-level card
• Straight roller design threads through wrapped sections
• Sells faster than five of the six others here
• Black finish, the default for dark hair

Cons:

• Only 18 pins per card, so refills come often
• No tip coating stated anywhere in the listing
• Feature copy gives no construction detail
• No published warranty

2. Goody SlideProof XXL Bobby Pins — Most versatile

The one buyers choose most often in this group, and the only box here built around a slide-resistant claim rather than raw length.

Best for: one box that handles both sections and stray strands Skip it if: you want published tip or coating details

Goody sells this as an XXL pin, and the packaging measures 0.38 x 4.5 x 3.5 in with 16 pins inside at a total 1.28 oz. Compare that to the 0.28 g on the Roller Pins card and the difference in metal weight per pin is obvious even without a length figure. These are substantially heavier pins.

That weight is the case for them. A heavier-gauge pin resists springing open under the load of dense hair, which is the failure most people describe as slipping. Goody positions the range as pain-free and suitable for all hair types, and the SlideProof name is the whole pitch. Take that as a claim, not a measurement.

This is also the pick with the strongest signal from shoppers: it moves faster than any other pin in this comparison by a wide margin. That is not proof of performance, but it does mean repeat buyers keep coming back to the same box.

The honest weakness is data. Goody's bullet list for this listing drifts into detangling comb copy, and no length figure appears anywhere, so you are trusting XXL as a category rather than a number. At 16 pins it is the smallest count in the set.

Pros:

• The one buyers choose most often here, by a clear margin
• Heaviest metal per pin among the low-priced picks
• Second-cheapest of the seven
• Slide-resistant design is the listing's core claim

Cons:

• No pin length published, only "XXL"
• Smallest count in the set at 16
• Feature bullets describe a comb, not the pins
• No tip finish or coating stated

3. Wenobby U Shaped Heavy Duty Hair Pins for Buns — Best for pros

A hundred U-shaped pins split across two boxes, which is how a working kit should arrive.

Best for: stylists pinning bun after bun and splitting stock between two bags Skip it if: you need the pressure of a two-legged bobby pin

These are not bobby pins in the strict sense. They are U pins, 2.8 in long, brown, 100 of them at a combined 5.29 oz. Wenobby ships them in two boxes of 50, which the listing frames as one for home and one for travel. For anyone working out of a bag, that packaging alone is worth noticing.

U pins solve a specific problem. A bobby pin clamps hair between two legs, and in a very dense bun that clamp can be forced open. A U pin has no spring to defeat: you slide it in against the direction of the twist and the bun's own tension holds it. Wenobby describes smooth round ball tips and a coated surface that will not stain or tangle. Both are the manufacturer's claims, though ball tips on a U pin are near-standard.

At the third-lowest price position with 100 pins, this is the best count-to-cost ratio among the cheaper picks in the set.

The catch is technique. U pins need a bun already gathered and twisted. They will not tack a single loose section flat against the scalp the way a ridged bobby pin does, and if that is your main use, this box will frustrate you. The brown finish also shows on black hair.

Pros:

• 100 pins across two separate storage boxes
• No spring to fatigue under heavy hair
• Coated ball tips claimed to prevent snagging
• Third-cheapest here despite the highest count among entry picks

Cons:

• U shape cannot flatten a loose section
• Brown only, visible on dark hair
• Needs a gathered bun to work at all
• Shorter than four other picks at 2.8 in

4. Tyqour 30pcs Jumbo Bobby Pins — Runner-up

The longest pin in this comparison at 3.35 in, and the only gold finish on offer.

Best for: gold-finish pins on light or highlighted hair Skip it if: you go through pins fast

Tyqour publishes 3.35 in, which ties the Aswewamt set for the longest reach here and beats the Diane pins by 0.85 in. The set holds 30 gold pins, and the listing describes a curved profile intended for buns and updos. Gold is the differentiator: every other pick is black or brown, so if your hair is blonde, highlighted or light brown, this is the only finish in the group that disappears rather than announces itself.

Curved plus long is a sensible combination for dense hair. The curve follows the skull, so the pin sits flatter and pulls less at the entry point, while the extra length gives you something to anchor against on the far side of the section.

Tyqour also sits at the mid price position, the only pick in this set that does, which puts it between the cheap Goody cards and the higher-priced bulk boxes.

Two real weaknesses. Only one seller lists it, which is the thinnest supply situation in the group. And at 30 pins it is the slowest-selling of all seven here by sales position, with no published weight or dimensions to tell you how heavy the metal actually is. You are buying on the length figure and the colour.

Pros:

• Longest published length in the set at 3.35 in
• Only gold finish among the seven picks
• Curved profile sits flat against the scalp
• Mid price position, between the cheap cards and bulk boxes

Cons:

• Only one seller lists it
• No published weight or gauge information
• The slowest seller of the seven
• 30 pins is a small stash for the price position

How many pins does one updo really need?

More than you think, and this is where count columns get misread. A single French twist on thick hair commonly takes 8 to 15 pins. A ballet bun with a wrapped base can take 20. Multiply that by the pins that vanish into bathroom drains and car seats and the maths changes fast.

Run the numbers against the boxes here:

• 16 to 18 pins (Goody SlideProof XXL, Goody Roller Pins): roughly one full updo, or a week of simple pinning. A restock item.
• 30 to 40 pins (Tyqour, Diane): two to three full updos, or about a month of daily light use.
• 50 pins (Aswewamt): an event kit with margin for loss.
• 100 to 120 pins (Wenobby, MORGLES): a season, or a working stylist's month.

The best professional bobby pins for thick hair are not automatically the ones in the biggest box. A 120-pin box of pins that are too short for your density is 120 wasted pins. Buy a small card first, confirm the length holds your hair, then scale up to the bulk box in the same length class.

5. Aswewamt 50 Black Jumbo Bobby Pins — Best minimal setup

Fifty curved pins at 3.34 in, which is the shortest shopping list that covers an entire event without a refill.

Best for: one purchase that covers a wedding or an event season Skip it if: you prefer a shorter pin near the hairline

Aswewamt publishes the clearest length statement in the set: 3.34 inches, or 85mm, spelled out in both units. Fifty curved jumbo pins in black, at 5.47 oz total, which works out to substantial metal per pin. The listing describes them as suitable for weddings, parties and daily use, and calls out longer and thicker hair specifically.

Fifty is the sweet spot number. It is enough to pin two or three heads for a wedding party with pins left over for the reception repairs, without committing to a hundred-plus box you will still be working through in two years. Combine that with near-maximum length and black finish, and this is the most straightforward event purchase in the group.

Where it loses out is finish detail and near-scalp work. The listing names quality metal, sturdy and durable, but says nothing about tip coating, unlike Diane and Wenobby. A 3.34 in pin is also unwieldy at the hairline: too much pin sticks out for tidy edge work, so you will want something shorter alongside it. It sits in the higher price group here, which is a lot to pay when the Goody card delivers 3 in for far less.

Pros:

• Length stated precisely, 3.34 in / 85mm
• 50 pins, sized for a full event without a refill
• Curved profile with a heavy 5.47 oz total weight
• Black finish for dark hair

Cons:

• No tip coating or finish stated
• Too long for edges and baby hairs
• Sits in the higher price group despite fewer pins than two rivals
• No dimensions published beyond the pin length

6. MORGLES Large Bobby Pins Brown — Best upgrade

The largest box here at 120 pins, with the ridged grip pattern most people picture when they think of a bobby pin.

Best for: brown-haired buyers who never want to reorder Skip it if: your hair is dark and a brown pin would show

MORGLES ships 120 brown pins at 2.75 in, total weight 6.35 oz, in a clear plastic storage box. This is the highest count of the seven and the heaviest package overall. The listing calls out extra thick hair by name and describes a crinkle in the middle on one side, which is the ridged construction that pins hair against the flat leg.

That ridge is why this box earns its place next to the U-pin sets. A ridged pin does one thing well: it holds a small section flat against the scalp without needing a bun to lock into. If your styling involves tucking, twisting back and flattening, ridged pins are what you reach for, and 120 of them means you can leave a handful in every bag you own.

The trade-offs are colour and length. Brown reads clearly on black hair, so dark-haired buyers should look at the Goody or Aswewamt picks instead. At 2.75 in this is shorter than four other picks here, and it sits in the higher price group while offering less length than the cheaper Goody card. The listing publishes no dimensions for the box itself.

Pros:

• Highest count in the set at 120 pins
• Ridged grip pattern, best for flattening sections
• Clear storage box keeps them sorted
• Heaviest total package at 6.35 oz

Cons:

• Brown only, visible on dark hair
• Shorter than four other picks at 2.75 in
• Higher price group despite modest length
• No box dimensions or tip finish published

7. Diane 2.5" Curved Black Bobby Pins — Best premium

The shortest and most discreet pin here, and the one with the most detail published about how it treats your scalp.

Best for: wraps, flyaways and finishing work close to the scalp Skip it if: you need to anchor a very heavy bun

Diane goes into more detail than anyone else in this set. The pins measure 2.5 in, come 40 to a pack at 27.2 g total, and the listing specifies coated ball tips designed to glide through hair without snagging, a curve that hugs the scalp, and long-lasting tension for repeat use. Individual pin dimensions are given as 0.19 x 2.75 x 0.06 in. Those are claims, but they are specific claims, which is more than most listings here manage.

This is the finishing pin. At 2.5 in it is the shortest of the seven, which means it disappears near the hairline instead of protruding. Diane's own copy names doobie wraps, protective styles, flyaways and baby hairs, and that is exactly the job it suits. Pair it with one of the long picks rather than treating it as your only box.

The problem is price against length. Diane sits at the top price position in this comparison while offering the least reach, so if your core complaint is pins sliding out of a dense bun, this is the wrong purchase. It also sells slower than the Goody options and the Wenobby set.

Pros:

• Most detailed construction claims in the set
• Coated ball tips stated for snag-free styling
• Shortest pin here, so it stays hidden at the hairline
• Curved to sit flat against the scalp

Cons:

• Highest price position in the set
• Shortest reach of all seven at 2.5 in
• Not enough length for a heavy bun anchor
• Sells slower than four other picks here

Colour, finish and the visibility problem

Colour is the cheapest mistake to avoid, and half this set gets it wrong for dark hair. Four picks are black: Goody Roller Pins, Goody SlideProof XXL, Aswewamt and Diane. Two are brown: Wenobby and MORGLES. One is gold: Tyqour.

Brown pins on black hair are visible from across a room. Gold pins on black hair are jewellery, whether you intended them to be or not. So the shortlist for very dark hair is smaller than the shortlist for the category, which is worth knowing before you buy the 120-pin box.

Surface finish is the other half of it. Wenobby says its pins are coated so they will not stain or tangle. Diane says the tips are coated to prevent snagging. MORGLES says its metal is not easy to fade. The three Goody and Aswewamt listings say nothing on the subject. That does not mean the pins are unfinished. It means you cannot check.

For light and highlighted hair, the pool is genuinely thin. Tyqour's gold pins are the only pick here in a light finish, and they are also the longest at 3.35 in, which makes the decision easy if that describes you.

What the listings do not tell you about thick hair

Every listing in this group leans on the same phrase, and none of them back it with a measurement. Here is what is missing across all seven:

• Wire gauge. Nobody publishes it. Gauge is what determines whether a pin springs open under load, and total package weight is only a rough proxy for it.
• Spring tension. Diane claims long-lasting tension. No pick states a figure, and there is no standard to state one against.
• Coating durability. Three listings mention a coating. None say how many uses it survives.
• Rust resistance. Not stated by any pick, which matters if pins live in a damp bathroom.

So how should you judge a pin the listing barely describes? Three checkable signals:

1. Published length in inches or millimetres, not a size word. "XXL" and "jumbo" mean whatever the seller wants.
2. Total weight against count. Divide one by the other. Heavier per pin usually means thicker wire.
3. A named grip pattern. Ridged, curved, straight or U. Each does a different job, and the listing that names it has thought about the product.

Judge the best professional bobby pins for thick hair on those three, and the marketing language stops mattering.

The verdict

Goody Black Roller Pins are the best professional bobby pins for thick hair for most buyers, because they clear the 3 in threshold that separates a pin that spans a dense section from one that sits on top of it, and they do it at the lowest price position of these seven. Buy one card, confirm the length solves your slipping, then scale up.

Two conditions flip that. First, if you are pinning more than one head a day, buy the Wenobby U-shaped set instead. A hundred pins in two boxes at 2.8 in gives you a working stash, and the U shape has no spring to defeat under a heavy bun. Second, if your hair is blonde, highlighted or light brown, go to the Tyqour set. It is the only gold finish here and the longest pin in the comparison at 3.35 in, so you get maximum reach and an invisible finish in one purchase.

The runner-up's exact advantage is that 3.35 in figure. Tyqour reaches 0.35 in further than the Goody card, which is the largest margin available in this group. What it gives up is supply and stock: one seller, 30 pins, and no published weight to tell you how thick the wire is. Goody wins on price, availability and a track record going back to 2009.

FAQ

Are professional bobby pins for thick hair worth paying more for?

Professional bobby pins for thick hair are worth the step up only when the extra money buys length or count. Diane sits at the top price position here with the shortest pin at 2.5 in, while the Goody card delivers 3 in at the lowest. Pay more for 100-plus pins or a longer reach, not for the word professional on the packet.

Is a jumbo bobby pin worth it if I only wear one bun a day?

A jumbo bobby pin is worth it for a single daily bun, because the failure you are trying to fix is length, not quantity. An 18-pin card of 3 in Goody Roller Pins covers a week of simple pinning. Start there before committing to the 120-piece MORGLES box, which locks you into 2.75 in whether it suits your density or not.

What length bobby pin should I use for very thick hair?

The length to use for very thick hair starts around 2.75 in and runs to 3.35 in in this group. Aswewamt states 3.34 in / 85mm and Tyqour states 3.35 in, the two longest here. Diane's 2.5 in curved pins are 0.85 in shorter and better suited to edges, wraps and flyaways than to anchoring a heavy bun.

Wenobby U pins or MORGLES ridged pins for a thick bun?

Choose between Wenobby U pins and MORGLES ridged pins by the job. Wenobby's 100 U-shaped pins at 2.8 in lock into a bun that is already gathered and twisted, with no spring to force open. MORGLES gives you 120 ridged pins at 2.75 in that flatten a loose section against the scalp. Buns favour Wenobby, tucking favours MORGLES.

What mistake do people make buying bobby pins for thick hair?

The mistake people make buying bobby pins for thick hair is ordering the biggest box first. A 120-count set in the wrong length is 120 pins you will not use, and colour compounds it: brown pins show plainly on black hair. Test a small card in one length, confirm it holds, then buy the bulk box in that same length.

Start with a single card of the Goody Black Roller Pins. Three inches costs you almost nothing to try, and within one morning you will know whether length was the problem or whether you need the U-pin approach instead. That one test saves you from a bulk box in the wrong specification. If you already know long pins hold your hair, skip the trial and go straight to the count that matches your week: 50 for an event, 100 or more for a working kit. Pin length is the only variable here you can verify from the listing, so let it lead.

Last updated: September 23, 2026. Product availability re-checked.

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.